It follows Kathy, a food critic in New York City. Her parents ask her to come home for Christmas, and there she meets a handsome police officer, which now complicates her situation.

Christmas at the Holly Hotel

Susan and Henry are hosting a dinner party, while trying to make good on a lie concerning the recent death of their father. Unexpected guests arrive, causing the night to unravel despite Susan's best efforts.

The Dinner Parting

Sparks fly between a woman and a firefighter when she returns home to Holly, Michigan, to plan her best friend's wedding.